1956

• Goodbye My Fancy

1957

• Jane

• The Tender Trap — Nov 21–23

1958

• The Happiest Millionaire

• The Man Who Came to Dinner

1959

• Finian’s Rainbow — May 15–16

• The Barretts of Wimpole Street — Nov 13–14

1960

• Kiss Me Kate — May 5–7

• My Three Angels — Nov 10–12

1961

• Auntie Mame — May 4–6

• South Pacific — Nov 17–19

1962

• Design for Murder — Jun 1–2

• Harvey — Nov 9–10

1963

• Annie Get Your Gun — Apr 25–27

• Rebecca — Nov 15–16

1964

• The Man in the Dog Suit — Apr 16–17

• My Fair Lady — Nov 6–8

1965

• Our Town — Apr 1–4

• The Sound of Music — Nov 5–7

1966

• Never Too Late — Apr 22–23

• You Can’t Take It With You — Dec 9–10

1967

• Monique — Apr 28–29

• The King and I — Nov 10–11, 17–18

1968

• Mary, Mary — Apr 26–27

• Born Yesterday — Nov 22–23

1969

• Only an Orphan Girl — Apr 25–26

• Funny Girl — Nov 14–15, 21–22xt goes here

1970

• Cactus Flower — Apr 10–11, 17–18

• Oklahoma! — Nov 13–14, 20–21

1971

• The Odd Couple — Apr 16–17, 23–24

• Anything Goes — Nov 12–13, 19–20

1972

• Plaza Suite — Apr 21–22, 28–29

• The Dark at the Top of the Stairs — Fall

1973

• See How They Run — May 4–5, 11–12

• Promises, Promises — Nov 9–10

1974

• Mr. Roberts — Apr 26–27

• Fiddler on the Roof — Nov 22–23

1975

• A Streetcar Named Desire — Apr 25–26

• Gypsy — Nov 21–23

1976

• The Prisoner of Second Avenue — Apr 9–10

1977

• Arsenic and Old Lace — Spring

• Guys and Dolls — Nov 18–19

1978

• West Side Story — Spring

• How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying — Fall

1979

• Bus Stop — May 4–5

• The Music Man — Fallption text goes here

1980

• Mame — Apr 25–26

• Barefoot in the Park — Fall

1981

• Grease — Spring

• The Trial of Mary Dugan — Nov 5–8

1982

• Li’l Abner — Spring

• South Pacific — Nov 5–6

1983

• Bye Bye Birdie — Apr 15–16

• The Death and Life of Sneaky Fitch — Nov 11–12

1984

• Barnum — May 11–12

• One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest — Nov 16–17

1985

• Anything Goes — May 3–4

1986

• Deathtrap — Jan 24–25

• Pippin — May 2–3

• God’s Favorite — Nov 7–8

1987

• The Unsinkable Molly Brown — May 1–2

• Brighton Beach Memoirs — Nov 20–21

1988

• Man of La Mancha — May 6–7

1989

• The Bad Seed — Jan 27–28

• The Wizard of Oz — May 12–13

• Blithe Spirit — Nov 17–18

1990

• Hello, Dolly! — Apr 20–21

• Steel Magnolias — Nov 16–17

1991

• 42nd Street — May 3–4

• Music and Memories (35th Anniversary Revue) — Part 1

1992

• Cinderella — Apr 24–25

• Biloxi Blues — Nov 20–22

1993

• Funny Girl — Apr 2–3

• Crimes of the Heart — Nov 19–20

1994

• The Pajama Game — May 6–7

• A Midsummer Night’s Dream — Nov 11–12

1995

• Fiddler on the Roof — Apr 28–29

• Nunsense — Nov 17–19

1996

• Into the Woods — Apr 26–28

• Rumors — Oct 25–26, Nov 1–2

1997

• Fabulous 40th Anniversary Show — Jan 24–25

• Tony ’n Tina’s Wedding — Mar 1, Jun 13

• Carousel — Apr 25–26

• Knock ’Em Dead — Nov 16 & Jan 23, 1998

1998

• Once Upon a Mattress — Apr 24–25

• Arsenic and Old Lace — Nov 21–22

1999

• Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat — Apr 23–24

• God’s Favorite — Nov 19–20

2000

• Dancing at Lughnasa — Nov 10–11, 17–18

2001

• Rhythm of Broadway — Jun 15–17

• The Amorous Ambassador — Nov

2002

• Annie — Apr

• Sentimental Journey — Jun

• The Cemetery Club — Nov

2003

• Bye Bye Birdie — Apr

• The Butler Did It — Nov 14–15, 21–22

2004

• Barefoot in the Park — Nov

2005

• South Pacific — Apr

• Ghost of a Chance — Nov

2006

• Falsettos — May

• Life with Father — Nov

2007

• Love Letters — Feb

• Grease — Apr

• Bravo, Broadway — Nov

2009

• The Best Christmas Pageant Ever — Dec

2011

• Rumors — Mar

• The Nerd — Dec 9–10

2012

• Fox on the Fairway — May 31–Jun 2

• SCORE! A Musical Showcase Fundraiser — Dec 1

2013

• Li’l Abner — Feb 21–23

• You Can’t Take It With You — May 2–4

• All in the Timing — Nov 21–23

• Home for the Holidays – Variety Show — Dec 13–14

2014

• Hay Fever — Mar 13–16

• Steel Magnolias — Sep 11–13

2015

• Much Ado About Nothing — Apr 23–25

• Home for the Holidays – Variety Show — Dec 5

2016

• Noises Off — Apr 21–23

• 1776 — Jul 23–25

• Home for the Holidays – Variety Show — Dec 10

2017

• Leading Ladies — Jun 22–24

• The 39 Steps — Sep 22–23

• The Best Christmas Pageant Ever — Dec 8–10

2018

• Love Letters — Feb 22–24

• Christmas Carol High School — Dec 14–15

2019

• Jake’s Women (Staged Reading) — Mar 30

• Willy Wonka — Jun 14–15

• A Few Good Men — Nov 8–9

• A Christmas Story —Dec 6-7

2021

• Godspell — Sep 10–11

2022

• Seussical! — Oct 28–29

2023

• Farce of Nature — Mar 3–4

• Disaster — 2023 Season

2024

• Rumors — 2024 Season

• 9 to 5 — 2024 Season

2025

• The Dinner Party - 2025 Season

• The Prom -2025 Season

2026

• The Game’s Afoot! - 2026